At Apple’s annual shareholder meeting in April, Steve Jobs
waxed lyrical about the MacBook Pro, a laptop powered by an
Intel Core Duo chip. “Everyone wants a MacBook Pro because they are so
bitchin’,” he said. There is certainly no doubt the laptop is one
smokin’ hot machine. Literally.
Since early March, shortly after MacBook Pro’s debut, users started posting
heat-related complaints to Apple-related internet forums, claiming
the machine was too hot to handle at times.
“Many users are also reporting that their MacBook Pros become extremely
hot to handle, especially in the area above the F keys and underneath the notebook
itself. In fact, my MacBook Pro gets so hot that placing it
in your hands is almost unbearable, and leaving it on a bare
lap is next to impossible. According to Apple, the MacBook Pro should
never become hot to the point of being uncomfortable,” wrote Tuan Nguyen,
a writer with DailyTech.com.
Apple also came under fire for not acknowledging the heat-related problem promptly
and publicly, along with other complaints that the notebook also makes an irritating
whining sound. When a user took his machine apart, and posted an explanation
and a link to the MacBook Pro service manual on the Something Awful
forums (forums.somethingawful.com) in
an effort to help others fix their heat issues, Apple served the webmaster of
Something Awful with a cease and desist order, demanding
that the link to the service manual be removed on grounds of copyright
infringement. “Apple reserves its right to contact your [Something
Awful] Internet Service Provider in the event you do not comply with these
demands,” said the letter, which the webmaster has posted
on the site.
Then the tech giant frustrated more users with another strange move on May 16.
The company quietly released a MacBook Pro firmware update without explaining
what it does, leaving tons of users to figure it out on their own.
“May I know what the MacBook Pro SMC [System Management Control] Update
does?” asked a user dubbed Readon on Apple’s official support forum.
“It supposedly allows fans to run faster so my laptop finally
becomes a laptop, that is I do not have to wear heat guards in order
to prevent my MacBook Pro from scorching the skin off my thighs.”
True enough; within hours of the update, users began reporting that it seemed
to increase the notebook’s use of fans and claimed that their machines
were now running a lot cooler.
But that didn’t stop a group of enthusiasts from calling for “a
day of action” against Apple, encouraging all MacBook Pro owners
experiencing problems to call Apple Support on May 20. “Apple seems to
be taking these annoyances very lightly, and as such, something needs
to be done,” the group’s organizer wrote on the osx86project.org
website. “We need to let Apple know we’re tired of them not paying
attention to our complaints…. This is the best way we can hold Apple accountable.
It’s our duty to make sure they know we won’t tolerate hacks and
unsupported fixes to fix an issue that shouldn’t be there.
This is nothing malicious and we do it with the most admirable of reasons –
telling Apple we love their characteristically high quality and won’t
settle for less.”
Still, Apple is silent. Neither did they respond to our queries on what they’ve
done or plan to do about the purported problems and the purpose of the firmware
update, or comment on a recent report in Engadget (www.engadget.com).
According to the tech site, Apple has included “a warning in the computer’s
manual, advising customers not to use their laptops on their laps:
‘Do not leave the bottom of your MacBook Pro in contact with your lap
or any surface of your body for extended periods. Prolonged contact with your
body could cause discomfort and potentially a burn.’”
The word “laptop” doesn’t appear in the MacBook’s manual
either, the site added, sparking Apple defenders to point out that Apple has
never used the word “laptop” in any of their pages for the MacBook
Pro, the MacBook or any of their portables, past or present, always either “notebook”
or “portable.”
“For those who feel the heat issues are a detriment to the term ‘laptop’,
I think the main draw of these devices isn’t the ability to sit it on
your lap, but more so the fact that it’s portable,” wrote one Engadget
user dubbed Striggity. Others, however, saw the lighter side of it. “I
can see it being a virtue come November,” wrote a user dubbed Gloss, on
AppleInsider.com.
Is this controversy just a lot of hot air? MacBook Pro owners should email
us at TheBuzz@thewavemag.com or
call our anonymous Buzz line at (408) 467-3255.